By: Rana Tasaduq Hussain

The alleged death of 13-year-old Hafiza Fatima Asghar following torture at the residence of a senior FIA officer inside Police Lines Headquarters, located in Sector H-11 of the federal capital, has raised serious questions about the credibility of law enforcement agencies and government accountability.

Fatima Asghar, daughter of Asghar Ali, belonged to a poor family from South Punjab. She was a Hafiza-e-Quran and was working as a domestic worker at the residence. According to reports, there were alleged signs of torture and burns caused by an electric iron on her body. She was shifted to Quaid-e-Azam Hospital in critical condition, where she died during treatment.

According to reports, the incident took place on the evening of November 14, and the police were informed on November 15. This was not an ordinary residence but a house located inside the sensitive government premises of Police Lines, reportedly associated with Muhammad Bin Ashraf, a Grade-19 officer and Director FIA Gujranwala Zone.

According to reports, Muhammad Bin Ashraf was removed from his position on the instructions of the Ministry of Interior. Reports also indicate the arrest of his wife and another domestic employee working at the house.

The criminal responsibility of all nominated individuals will be determined by the court. However, removing an officer from his position is not a substitute for accountability. Investigations must establish who employed the girl, who knew her age, who was responsible for her care, and what other members of the household knew about the alleged torture.

According to reports, FIR No. 619/26 was registered at Shams Colony Police Station, Islamabad, under Section 302 of the Pakistan Penal Code, on the complaint of her father, Asghar Ali.

According to her father, he was informed that his daughter had suddenly fallen ill and had been shifted to hospital. Later, he received the news of her death and noticed marks of torture on her body. He demanded a post-mortem examination, determination of the actual cause of death, and legal action against those responsible.

According to a report, an alleged attempt was made to persuade the parents not to pursue the case. If this allegation is correct, it constitutes a separate matter involving possible interference in the process of justice.

Meanwhile, the wife of the FIA director and a Qari were presented before a judicial magistrate.

The accused were produced before Judicial Magistrate Naima Ift, where the court handed both of them over to the police on a four-day physical remand for further investigation.

The magistrate was informed that the domestic worker had been subjected to torture with sticks. It was also stated that the incident of torture had been recorded in CCTV footage, while sticks had also been recovered from the possession of the accused.

The court approved a four-day physical remand of both accused for further investigation.

For Federal Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi, this is not merely a murder case but a decisive test of the impartiality of the institutions under his authority and their commitment to the supremacy of law. The FIA falls under the administrative jurisdiction of the Ministry of Interior, while Islamabad Police is responsible for enforcing the law in the federal capital.

The following questions are now being raised for the Interior Minister:


  • Will he meet the affected family and ensure its protection?
  • Will an independent Joint Investigation Team (JIT) be formed under an officer outside the administrative chain of the FIA and the relevant Islamabad Police authorities?
  • Will the post-mortem and forensic evidence be preserved and presented before the court and the family?
  • Will those allegedly pressuring the parents be identified?
  • Will departmental investigations against the relevant officer go beyond merely removing him from his position?
  • Will investigations be conducted into the presence of underage domestic workers in Police Lines and other government residential areas?

Mohsin Naqvi will have to prove that official positions, institutional affiliations and influence do not grant anyone exemption from the law.

Under the Islamabad Capital Territory Domestic Workers Act 2022, employing a child under the age of 16 as a domestic worker is prohibited. The Child Protection Act 2018 also provides a legal framework for the protection of children.

If Fatima Asghar was indeed working as a domestic worker at the age of 13, the individuals responsible for her employment and the relevant legal violations must also be investigated. The question is how a minor girl continued working at the residence of a government officer and where the monitoring system of law enforcement agencies was.

The Rizwana case, the death of a minor domestic worker in Ranipur, and similar incidents reported from Sheikhupura have already highlighted the dangers of child domestic labour. Fatima's case is even more concerning because the alleged incident took place inside Police Lines itself.


  1. An independent JIT should be established in accordance with the legal procedure, headed by an officer outside the relevant administrative chain of the FIA and Islamabad Police.
  2. The post-mortem report, forensic findings, residential security records and other relevant evidence should be preserved.
  3. In addition to murder, applicable legal provisions concerning violence against children, prohibited child labour, unlawful confinement, concealment of evidence and threats should be reviewed.
  4. Legal assistance and protection should be provided to Asghar Ali and his family.
  5. Impartial departmental investigations should be conducted into the relevant officer and the household arrangements.
  6. A legal monitoring system against child labour should be implemented in Police Lines, FIA residential facilities, Judges Colony and other government residential areas.
  7. The Interior Minister should answer before Parliament and announce practical reforms within a specified period.

Fatima was a young girl who had memorised the Holy Quran and deserved education, protection and a secure future. Her father's only demand is that the actual cause of his daughter's death be determined and those responsible be punished in accordance with the law.

The matter should not end with a few arrests, an administrative notification and formal statements.

This is a test of the credibility of the Ministry of Interior under Mohsin Naqvi, the impartiality of the FIA and the accountability of Islamabad Police. Its outcome will not be determined through press conferences or transfers, but through a complete investigation, evidence-based judicial proceedings and accountability without discrimination.

Police Lines should be a place of protection under the law, not a symbol of silence against alleged abuses taking place at the residences of influential individuals.

Justice for Fatima. Investigation into Police Lines. No one is above the law.

Editorial Note: Information regarding torture, burns caused by an electric iron, arrests and alleged pressure on the parents is based on allegations and media reports. The actual facts will emerge through the post-mortem, forensic evidence and judicial proceedings. There are differences in some reports regarding the girl's hometown. All accused persons are presumed innocent until proven guilty by a court of law.