The debate over the creation of new provinces has, in reality, become a debate about shifting the centre of power. In the past, during the two previous periods of martial law, the Chief Martial Law Administrators successfully used the argument of transferring powers to the grassroots level as a means of expanding their own reach and keeping politicians away from the public.
It was claimed that public issues would be resolved at people's doorsteps and at the grassroots level. However, in practice, these local government representatives or Basic Democracies (BD) members failed to go beyond serving as instruments of the dictators. As a result, with the end of martial law, the system was dismantled along with its representatives. Although, if implemented in its true spirit, this system can successfully serve public convenience and welfare, as it does in democratic countries around the world.
However, democratic governments in Pakistan have always faced the problem of not being allowed to deliver. After two and a half, three, or three and a half years, certain circles begin to identify governance shortcomings or corruption, and the government is removed on one pretext or another.
The current government has not yet completed three years, but the slogan of a system collapse has already been raised, with the establishment of more provinces being proposed as a solution. According to the plan, whose new maps have also been prepared, the four existing provinces are to be divided into twelve provinces.
A heated debate has now begun across the country on this issue. However, the very forums where this debate should take place have yet to formally address the matter: the provincial assemblies, the National Assembly, and the Senate.
The Constitution provides a procedure for dividing provinces, which is as follows:
Changing provincial boundaries or creating a new province falls under Article 239, Clause (4).
- Article 239(4): If a constitutional amendment bill seeks to alter the boundaries of a province, it can only be presented to the President for approval after being passed by the relevant provincial assembly with a two-thirds majority of its total membership. In addition, the required two-thirds majority in both houses of Parliament is also necessary for the constitutional amendment.
- Article 1(2):
Lahore 26°C
Islamabad 25°C


